Joyfully, I walked the 20 blocks to the theatre on a gorgeous NYC spring day.

With a bounce in my step I was anxious to return to my Broadway passion. This play was the first of six that are in my theatre line up.

The show is a very specific kind of musical that does not try to change your life.

Two Strangers Carry A Cake Across New York just wants to entertain you for two hours, distract you from outside chaos and make you laugh, sending you back out into the world slightly lighter.

When Dougal (Sam Tutty) and Robin (Christiani Pitts) meet at the airport, the setup practically winks at you.

He is the earnest Brit with a suitcase full of dreams and unresolved daddy issues. She is the jaded New Yorker who has already emotionally surrendered.

Of course they clash. Of course they are stuck together. Of course there is a very pricey wedding cake involved.

We have seen this rom com and we love it and that is the truth.  The show does not fight the formula. It treats it like a feature, not a flaw.

Robin is tasked with picking up the absurdly expensive cake in Brooklyn for her sister’s wedding to an older man who happens to be Dougal’s dad who flew the coop before he was born.

Dougal, in a burst of well-meaning enthusiasm, tags along. He is in New York to attend the wedding and jacked to rendezvous with the father he has never met. Robin is trying to get through the day without unraveling.

The score by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan is exactly what you want it to be…light, contemporary, and refreshingly clear. The lyrics actually tell the story, moving things forward. Surprisingly, Two Strangers is the team’s first musical. 

Dougal is all open-hearted chaos, seeing New York like it is a highlight reel. Robin counters with perfectly calibrated eye-roll energy, the kind that says she’s  been here, done that. Their chemistry does not hit you over the head. Rather, it sneaks up on you. A look, a pause, a moment.

Both characters are carrying more than just the cake.

The staging leans into the story line. Stacks of silver luggage that open up into fragments of the city…hotel rooms, restaurants, little pockets of life. It is clever and visually satisfying.

The audience was fully on board, the kind of easy engagement that tells you the show is doing exactly what it set out to do.

I never once glanced at my watch which, sadly, happens way too frequently.

Two Strangers does not pretend that a brief encounter will fix family wounds or neatly tie up emotional loose ends. It is not that kind of musical. It is more interested in the in-between, where two people actually see each other.

And then, like all good New York moments, it ends.

You step back outside. The city is loud again, electrified, uninterested in your emotional growth.

But, you are smiling.

Two Strangers Carry A Cake Across New York Longacre Theatre 220 West 48th Street New York City. Running time is 2 hours and 15 minutes with intermission.

.